To Disable Buff Effects or Not To Disable Buff Effects

OOC discussions directly related to Dasaria.

Should buff effects be disabled or not?

Poll ended at Fri Feb 05, 2010 4:25 pm

Yes, buff effects should be toned down.
29
74%
No, leave buff effects as they currently are.
10
26%
 
Total votes: 39

Peregrinus
2012 Best Screenshot Winner
Posts: 1806
Joined: Fri Sep 22, 2006 9:27 pm
Main Player Character: Phelan "Tennick" Almaran
Other PCs: Skia Sonnen
Bioware Username: Peregry
Location: Woodbridge, VA, USA

Re: To Disable Buff Effects or Not To Disable Buff Effects

Post by Peregrinus »

Gixxer Chixxer wrote:...and really, if the powers are so powerful as to make them overpowered if they cannot be seen, perhaps the spells in question need a debuff.
That's just it, the spells with the most obvious visuals have some of the most mundane and lower end spell effects. Take a look at the file I linked and which spells are changed:

- Mage Armor (and Greater)
A level 1 and level 3 spell, +4 Enchantment AC bonus and +6 Respectfully, nothing game breaking in and of themselves. A bread and butter spell, 99% of mages will have one of these, seriously, assume a mage is running this regardless.

- Protection from Alignment
A level 1 spell, +1 Deflection AC against (evil/good) protection from mind spells from (evil/good) casters. Again, pretty mundane.

- Protection from Arrows
A level 2 spell, dr 10/magic against ranged weapon attacks up to 10 damage/caster level. Pretty close to worthless honestly.

- Protection from Energy (and variants)
A large bunch of spells, varying in power. If you're up against a mage you should assume they have some form of elemental protection running anyway.

- Shield
A level 1 spell, +4 shield bonus to AC. A bread a butter spell, 99% of mages will cast this.

- Ghostly Visage (and ethereal variants)
Some decent power behinds these spells, the lower level one is, frankly, a joke past level 6 anyway.

And it bear repeating, for the umpteenth time, the spells will still have a visual effect, they will simply be more subdued.
- Peregrinus
Canas Delenda Est!
Remember to use the Dasaria Wiki!
User avatar
Redleafe
Dasarian Hero
Posts: 1193
Joined: Mon Oct 16, 2006 3:56 am
Main Player Character: Kyfier Redleafe
Other PCs: Volak Redleafe
Cpl. Vhannon "Bulldog" Briggs
Ru of Cuhanna
Bioware Username: Redleafe
Location: Ohio

Re: To Disable Buff Effects or Not To Disable Buff Effects

Post by Redleafe »

Mon-da-oth wrote:
Redleafe wrote:Hehe. You work for FEMA? Rhode working for FEMA brings a a sadistic little smile to my face actually. :twisted:
FEMA? Federal Emergancy Management Agency? Or do you mean PETA? People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals. Rhode working for PETA? LOL That would explain a lot, he is an animal after all.

I did mean PETA, hehe. I think Wired is onto something though, Rhode the head of FEMA....thats just wrong.
ImageImage

Kyfier Redleafe, Rebel of the Daybreak Alliance.
Volak Redleafe, Champion of the Redleafe Clan.
Istan Donnerly, Paladin of Tharon.
Twist of Cain
Commoner
Posts: 72
Joined: Fri Jan 29, 2010 8:01 am
Main Player Character: The Ravencry Family (MrGrendel)
Location: Behind you, right now.

Re: To Disable Buff Effects or Not To Disable Buff Effects

Post by Twist of Cain »

Hello :D

I think they should be disabled. I'd played on a server on NWN1 that had nearly all spell buff effects turned off, and found I liked it much better. Not only in terms of that you don't have lazerballz floating around mages, but actually not knowing if a person was buffed to the gills or not made some RP confrontations much more interesting.

As far as lore goes too, I think nearly all buff effects are invisible. Farmer Joe shouldn't be able to look at a mage and go, "Lookit that shiny ball, it means he has Lord Farkwizzle's Arrow Protection on..."

Even stoneskin etc annoys me because it covers up cool-looking equipment :(
AlexandrosGR
Commoner
Posts: 14
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2009 11:22 am
Main Player Character: Alexander Silverstar
Other PCs: Cabal
Location: Greece

Re: To Disable Buff Effects or Not To Disable Buff Effects

Post by AlexandrosGR »

Yes I agree that they ALL should be removed.
Cannot wait to see the face of someone that will ambush me thinking of Im unbuffed! (eveil grinz)

Erm I mean for rp reasons...
Nullus opportunus nex in meus pars
Alterity
Forum Troll
Posts: 3024
Joined: Sat May 31, 2008 3:21 pm
Main Player Character: Vanguard Captain Firin D'Adlaer
Other PCs: Korangar "The Wall"
Aaronn
Lumme Cirth'Arda
Glanin Redleafe
Heironius Blackaster
Artimaye Veraquez
Sir Hyel Loremaster
Alesan
Bioware Username: Alterity
Location: Canada (EST)

Re: To Disable Buff Effects or Not To Disable Buff Effects

Post by Alterity »

And it bear repeating, for the umpteenth time, the spells will still have a visual effect, they will simply be more subdued.
They'd still know you have buffs, many of the noticable cleric spells don't have changes anyways.
Sir Hyel Loremaster- Knight of Argentum Vigilo, Archmage of Ordo Magica , Slayer of Zumen the Winged Death, & Head Librarian of the Great Library of Cear- Captain Firin- Korangar "The Wall" - Lucian Rhaz - & Glanin Redleafe.
Wired
Retired
Posts: 8978
Joined: Fri Aug 17, 2007 9:13 pm

Re: To Disable Buff Effects or Not To Disable Buff Effects

Post by Wired »

Just shoot the guy in the robe.
Cum eos testibus arripuisses, eorum corda mentesque sequentur

10/2
Mad Dog Reno
2010 BEST SCREENSHOT WINNER!
Posts: 1163
Joined: Wed Apr 29, 2009 10:15 am
Main Player Character: Reno's
Other PCs: Renar Stenfinn, Reno Stormbeard, Ronald & Renold Bergfinn
Bioware Username: Mad_Dog_Reno
Location: Finland
Contact:

Re: To Disable Buff Effects or Not To Disable Buff Effects

Post by Mad Dog Reno »

DM Wired wrote:Just shoot the guy in the robe.

Hahaa... good advice and might work! :D
"Treat Others As You Would Like To Be Treated"
Image
Chars: Reno Stormbeard&Maddog, Renar Stenfinn, Rolf, Ronald & Renold Bergfinn, Benjamin & Henry Birdcherrygrow
The Explorer
Beat that & drank that
Posts: 3122
Joined: Sun Jan 21, 2007 6:55 pm
Main Player Character: Mordecai
Other PCs: Lorval Silverbeard, Kez Ryskill, Tobias Skyler Blyth, Tobin Scoobay
Location: Where I fall a slumber I dwell

Re: To Disable Buff Effects or Not To Disable Buff Effects

Post by The Explorer »

DM Wired wrote:Just shoot the guy in the robe.
http://www.entertonement.com/clips/wcgk ... -Ash-geek-

Mwahahahahahah the simplest suggestions always make for the quickest wit.
Image
"When faced with important decisions it's a 90% chance your initial choice is right for you."

Mordecai - Mischievous Mage of Cuhanna
Kez Ryskill - Decayed
Lorval Silverbeard - Stormbeard Defender
Peregrinus
2012 Best Screenshot Winner
Posts: 1806
Joined: Fri Sep 22, 2006 9:27 pm
Main Player Character: Phelan "Tennick" Almaran
Other PCs: Skia Sonnen
Bioware Username: Peregry
Location: Woodbridge, VA, USA

Re: To Disable Buff Effects or Not To Disable Buff Effects

Post by Peregrinus »

And people wonder why Phelan dresses like a ranger.
- Peregrinus
Canas Delenda Est!
Remember to use the Dasaria Wiki!
izzul
Dasarian Hero
Posts: 727
Joined: Thu Nov 12, 2009 12:54 pm
Main Player Character: Az-Kalla,Az-Kareem
Other PCs: Nadia Az-Kalla 20, Shades of Nuarari 20, Reepar 20, Derer 20, Izz 20,
Izzi 17,Izzul 18(duergar), Izzy 18(duergar), Ultim 20,Krueger Kareem 20,
Nicolai Az-Kareem 16,Sound to heaven 15,
Bioware Username: izzul
Location: Singapore, Asia
Contact:

Re: To Disable Buff Effects or Not To Disable Buff Effects

Post by izzul »

so now an idea to shoot someone looks like ranger?

btw..actually i like all the balls and spell buffs for the character..not just voting no without any reason..though i admit there are some that require a bit lessen to it..i think DM is the wisest to distinguish that and they do the best work for us..all opinions are respected and taken care by them without leaving even any of us here.... :)
Ultim(Sb)~Cathedral
Reepar(Sb)~215 crit
Nadia(M)~Lich
Nicolai(M)~Pander
Krueger(M)
Image
"collaboration=getting better result working together(provided one is on his best)"
Wired
Retired
Posts: 8978
Joined: Fri Aug 17, 2007 9:13 pm

Re: To Disable Buff Effects or Not To Disable Buff Effects

Post by Wired »

Alright, looks like the vote is in.

Remind me, this is a vote to remove the hampster balls, or just to use the 'less obtrusive' ones?
Cum eos testibus arripuisses, eorum corda mentesque sequentur

10/2
Sorc
Dasarian Scout
Posts: 357
Joined: Tue Jan 27, 2009 12:48 pm
Main Player Character: Az

Re: To Disable Buff Effects or Not To Disable Buff Effects

Post by Sorc »

As i figure from OP, and poll question, seems we talking about taking less obtrusive spells.. Please though dont replace mirror image effect... Mirror image is cool as it is now... replacement is worse..
One of The Mist chidren of First and Second blood
Image
Ron
Forum Troll
Posts: 2345
Joined: Sat Sep 23, 2006 12:45 am
Location: Illinois

Re: To Disable Buff Effects or Not To Disable Buff Effects

Post by Ron »

Remind me, this is a vote to remove the hampster balls, or just to use the 'less obtrusive' ones?
To me disable means remove, however effects other than the "hamster balls" don't really bother me. Except maybe the light spell, I find it annoying.
Satinka Onatah
Image
Evelond Formos

Re: To Disable Buff Effects or Not To Disable Buff Effects

Post by Evelond Formos »

It is possible to get the light effect without having the associated ball of light by casting the spell on an equipped item instead of yourself.
Mad Dog Reno
2010 BEST SCREENSHOT WINNER!
Posts: 1163
Joined: Wed Apr 29, 2009 10:15 am
Main Player Character: Reno's
Other PCs: Renar Stenfinn, Reno Stormbeard, Ronald & Renold Bergfinn
Bioware Username: Mad_Dog_Reno
Location: Finland
Contact:

Re: To Disable Buff Effects or Not To Disable Buff Effects

Post by Mad Dog Reno »

DM Wired wrote: Remind me, this is a vote to remove the hampster balls, or just to use the 'less obtrusive' ones?
Remove that damn hamster ball !
"Treat Others As You Would Like To Be Treated"
Image
Chars: Reno Stormbeard&Maddog, Renar Stenfinn, Rolf, Ronald & Renold Bergfinn, Benjamin & Henry Birdcherrygrow
Locked

Return to “General Discussion”